Mechanical Keyboard vs Hall Effect Keyboard | Features & Benefits

Mechanical Keyboard vs Hall Effect Keyboard | Features & Benefits

Keyboard use is a personal choice, but research shows that Hall effect keyboards seem to be becoming more popular than traditional mechanical keyboards. According to Market Research Future, the mechanical keyboard market size was valued at around $1.65 billion in 2023, expected to rise to $1.89 billion in 2024. 

In contrast, the Hall effect keyboard market is already valued at about $4.7 billion, projected to rise to over $5 billion by 2025. They both provide an exceptional user experience, but the differences in tactile feedback, customization, and smoothness make them suited to certain uses and personal preferences. 

GravaStar’s gaming keyboards are the ultimate mechanical experience, with hot-swappable switches and a compact 75% build. But for those who might be wondering if they still outstrip newer technology, keep reading to understand the differences between a mechanical keyboard vs Hall effect keyboard and which is best for you. 

What is a Mechanical Keyboard? 

A mechanical keyboard is a type of keyboard that uses individual mechanical switches for each key. These switches are composed of a housing, a spring, and a stem. When a key is pressed, the stem moves, allowing the metal contacts within the switch to connect and register the keystroke. 

This design provides satisfying tactile feedback and an audible click, adding to the typing experience. Switches come in three different types (linear, tactile, and clicky), each one with a different tactile and sound experience. 

Benefits of Using a Mechanical Keyboard 

Traditional mechanical keyboards offer appealing tactile feedback, are easily customizable, highly durable, and last for tens of millions of keystrokes. 

Tactile Feedback 

Mechanical keyboards offer distinct tactile feedback, which many users find satisfying. It’s also helpful for more accurate typing, as it’s immediately noticeable if a key press is missed.  

Customization 

Some mechanical keyboards are hot-swappable, letting you change switches without complication. This gives you freedom to choose the switch that feels and sounds best to you. 

Durability 

High-quality mechanical switches are designed to withstand extensive use, often rated for 50 million keystrokes or more. This makes them a long-lasting investment. 

N-Key Rollover and Anti-Ghosting 

Many mechanical keyboards support N-key rollover, which enables multiple keys to be pressed simultaneously without conflict. This feature is particularly beneficial for gamers and fast typists. 

Disadvantages of Using a Mechanical Keyboard 

Although they have many benefits, mechanical keyboards are expensive, noisier, and tend to be heavier compared to Hall effect keyboards. 

Cost 

Mechanical keyboards tend to be more expensive than others due to the complexity and quality of the individual switches. Their durability does make them worth the price, though. 

Noise Level 

The audible clicks produced by certain switch types can be disruptive in shared or quiet environments. Some switches are designed to be quieter for such settings, but they also have different tactile experiences to more noisy switches. 

Weight and Portability 

Mechanical keyboards are generally heavier and bulkier than other types, which may not be ideal for users needing a portable solution. 

What is a Hall Effect Keyboard? 

A Hall effect keyboard uses Hall effect sensors to detect key presses through magnetic fields rather than physical contact. Each key contains a magnet. When pressed, the movement of this magnet is detected by a Hall sensor, registering the keystroke. This contactless operation results in a much smoother and more consistent typing experience in Hall effect keys vs normal keys. 

Benefits of Using a Hall Effect Keyboard 

Hall effect keyboards are exceptionally durable, provide a smooth, comfortable typing experience, read variable key press depths, and have a customizable actuation point. 

Durability 

The contactless nature of Hall effect switches minimizes mechanical wear, because there are fewer moving parts. This extends the lifespan of the switches, making them highly durable. 

Customizable Actuation Point 

Users can adjust the actuation point (the distance a key travels before registering a press) tailoring the keyboard’s responsiveness to personal preferences. This isn’t possible on mechanical keyboards. 

Smooth Typing Experience 

The absence of physical contacts in the switches provides a frictionless and consistent keystroke. This can be a pleasing feeling to users who prefer a smooth, less tactile experience. 

Analog Control 

Some Hall effect keyboards can read variable key press depth. This is an excellent feature for analog input in games. 

Disadvantages of Using a Hall Effect Keyboard 

Hall effect technology makes these keyboards more expensive compared to mechanical ones, and they’re also harder to come by. You might struggle to find Hall effect keyboard switches, and strong magnetic fields can also disrupt their operation. 

Higher Cost 

The advanced technology and components involved in Hall effect keyboards often lead to a higher price point compared to traditional mechanical keyboards. 

Limited Availability 

Fewer manufacturers produce Hall effect keyboards, leading to a more limited selection. You may come up against challenges in finding specific models or features. 

Magnetic Field Sensitivity 

Strong external magnetic fields can potentially interfere with the keyboard’s operation, affecting performance in certain environments. 

Limited Switch Variety 

While you can also swap switches, there are fewer Hall effect keyboard switch options and fewer brands that offer different switches. 

How Do Mechanical and Hall Effect Keyboards Compare? 

Mechanical keyboards vs Hall effect keyboards differ in switch mechanisms, tactile feedback, noise, durability, customization, and gaming performance. Here’s a quick comparison: 


Mechanical Keyboard 

Hall Effect Keyboard 

Switch Mechanism 

Multiple switch types, with physical contacts for actuation. 

Sensors detect changes in the magnetic field to register keystrokes. No physical contacts. 

Tactile Feedback 

Spring-based with tactile or clicky feedback. Widely varied, depending on the switch used. 

Much less feedback than mechanical keyboards, if any at all. 

Noise 

May be silent or clicky, depending on the switch used. 

Quieter than mechanical in general, but also depends on the switch. 

Durability 

Rated from 10 to 100 million keystrokes depending on the model. 

Potentially higher lifespan due to fewer physical contact points. 

Gaming Performance 

Responsive, with established switch types. 

Analog input on certain models can give better control (eg. driving games). 

Customization 

Plenty of aftermarket options, including custom keycaps, switch mods, and open-source firmware. 

Fewer aftermarket parts, though some brands provide unique firmware features. 

Who Should Use Mechanical or Hall Effect Keyboards? 

Mechanical keyboards are a classical style that’s well loved by gamers, typists, and everyday users. Hall effect keyboards can provide a smooth, enjoyable experience for every user, but they’re best for users who want a silent and non-tactile experience. 

Gaming Enthusiasts 

Gaming enthusiasts often choose mechanical keyboards due to their responsive switches, which can be tailored to their gaming style. Features like N-key rollover and anti-ghosting help maintain smooth performance during fast-paced gameplay, while tactile or clicky switches offer feedback that can improve your precision. 

Hall effect keyboards can appeal to gamers who value customizable actuation points, allowing them to fine-tune key responsiveness for competitive play. The durability and smooth keystroke experience of Hall effect switches can be beneficial for long gaming sessions. 

Professional Typists 

Typists often prefer traditional mechanical switches for their tactile feedback, which improves typing speed and accuracy. Switches like Cherry MX Blue or similar tactile switches provide the satisfying “click” and feel that many professionals appreciate. 

Typists who need a silent and frictionless experience (like in an office) may prefer Hall effect keyboards. The smooth actuation reduces strain during extended typing, they’re quiet, and the customizable actuation point allows for a personalized feel. 

Programmers and Everyday Users 

Programmers and general users benefit from the wide variety of mechanical switch options, from quiet and linear for office environments to tactile and clicky for extra typing feedback. Durability and ergonomic designs are also handy for those spending hours at the keyboard. 

Those who want a futuristic typing experience or value the ultra-long lifespan of Hall effect keyboards may find them appealing. Adjustable actuation points and minimal maintenance requirements make them ideal for frequent, heavy use. 

Mechanical Keyboard vs Hall Effect Keyboard | FAQs 

How Does a Membrane Keyboard Differ from Mechanical and Hall Effect Keyboards? 

Membrane keyboards use a thin, flexible membrane layer to register keystrokes, relying on pressure to create contact between conductive traces. They lack the individual switches of mechanical keyboards or the magnetic field detection of Hall effect keyboards. Membrane keyboards are quieter and more affordable but offer less tactile feedback, durability, and customization compared to the other two types. 

Are Hall Effect Keyboards Better for Ergonomics? 

Hall effect keyboards can offer better ergonomics for some users due to their smooth, contactless key actuation. The absence of physical friction reduces finger fatigue during extended typing sessions. Customizable actuation points allow users to tailor the typing experience to their comfort, which can be handy for those with repetitive strain concerns. 

What Are the Energy Requirements for Mechanical vs Hall Effect Keyboards? 

Mechanical keyboards generally consume less power as their switches rely on simple physical contacts, especially in wired models. Hall effect keyboards, with their magnetic field sensors and sometimes extra features like customizable actuation, may use slightly more power, particularly in wireless configurations. 

The difference is minimal for most users and doesn’t impact usability. As long as you have an electric current, you’ll be able to use either one. 

Reading next

TKL vs 75% Keyboard: Which is Right for You?
PC Gaming Controller vs Mouse | Advantages of Each Option

Leave a comment

This site is protected by hCaptcha and the hCaptcha Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.